Free Agency Pitch Concepts: Who Owns the Ideas Afterward?
Three finalists have offered to show you ideas before you sign anything, or you are tempted to ask each for sample content. It feels like cheap insurance. It is really a decision about money, time and rights, and most buyers make it by default.
Why free concepts feel like a gift and behave like a liability
Here is an illustrative scenario, invented for this post. A brand gets concept decks from three finalists and hires the one with the best process. Two months later a rival brand launches a campaign resembling a losing finalist’s idea. Nobody need have copied anything. But the brand cannot say who owned that idea, who saw the deck, or where it travelled.
Free concepts create three problems. The agency spent unpaid time and quietly feels entitled to the work. You hold ideas of unclear status. And ideas drift, to the agency’s other clients or back into your own team’s briefs.
Wanting to see work before you hire is a reasonable instinct. The issue is not the request. It is that nobody decided the terms first.
Decision one: ask for spec work at all?
A concept deck proves the pitch team can produce attractive ideas with limited knowledge of your business. It does not prove how the execution team works month to month, whether they follow a brief, or how they handle revisions. That gap is why the site’s material on pitch teams versus execution teams matters here.
The good version of a pitch ask is modest: a strategic point of view on your actual problem, a short sample of how they would approach your audience, and a walkthrough of their process. The bad version is three finished posts per finalist, for a brand they have not researched, due in a week. That tests spare capacity, not quality.
For a harder test, use a paid pilot before the retainer. It shows real working behaviour under a normal contract.
Decision two: pay for it or do not ask
The rule of thumb: if you request bespoke creative from several agencies and expect them to bear the cost, you are asking for free labour from agencies that mostly lose. Offer a flat fee, or do not ask.
Even a modest fee changes the rights conversation, because it creates a transaction a contract can govern. State it in the brief before anyone starts. Agencies also volunteer concepts as part of how they sell, and you can accept while still setting terms. The options, with no figures because the right fee depends on scope:
| Option | Cost to agency | You receive | Rights by default |
|---|---|---|---|
| No spec | A few hours of senior time | A point of view and a feel for their process | Nothing in dispute |
| Paid concept round | Partly or fully covered | Concepts to evaluate, maybe use | Whatever the written terms say |
| Unpaid, volunteered | High, at their own risk | Ideas for evaluation only | Generally the agency |
Paying a fee does not automatically make you the owner of anything. The paperwork decides.
Who owns an unpaid concept, in plain terms
Rules differ by country, and by whether the work came from an employee, a contractor or an agency. Ask a lawyer licensed where the contract will be enforced.
The general principle: the US Copyright Office says that once you create an original work and fix it, you are its author and owner, and its circular on works made for hire describes the exceptions where a hiring party is treated as author. The UK government’s copyright guidance says protection arises automatically, and its page on licensing and selling copyright says a transfer needs a written, signed document. So a deck an agency made on its own account is the agency’s, and receiving it gives you at best a limited permission to look at it.
The US Copyright Office also says copyright protects expression and never ideas or concepts. Where that line falls for a campaign concept is a question for counsel, so do not rely on an idea being free to take.
Do not assume that receiving a deck means the right to use it. Do not forward it to the winner. Do not brief the winner to “do something like this.”
The one paragraph to put in writing before the pitch
Send it with the pitch brief, before work begins. It needs four elements:
- Unpaid concepts remain the agency’s property and are provided for evaluation only.
- You will not use, adapt or share them with anyone, including another agency, and may keep one copy, deleting or returning it on request after the decision.
- If you want to use a concept, you first agree a licence or assignment and a fee.
- The agency confirms the concepts contain no third-party material, such as unlicensed images or music, since you might be the one to publish.
For a paid round, the brief must say which deal you are buying: an assignment of rights in the paid concepts on payment, or a licence limited to evaluation. An illustrative template, not legal advice:
Concepts supplied without a fee remain the property of the agency and are supplied for evaluation only. The brand will not use, adapt or share them with any third party, including any other agency, and will delete or return its single evaluation copy on request after a decision. Any use requires a written licence or assignment and an agreed fee in advance. The agency confirms the concepts contain no third-party material it is not entitled to supply.
This belongs in the document you issue when running the RFP process. For the reverse direction, see what to put under NDA before a pitch.
What to do with the losing agencies’ ideas
Brief the winner from its own concept and your goals, never a loser’s deck. A bad brief: “Make it more like the second agency’s idea.” A good one: “Our goal is more sign-ups from existing customers this quarter. Build on your own concept.”
Send losers a short notice: thank them, confirm their concepts will not be used, and say materials will be deleted or returned on request. If the winner later proposes something close to a losing concept, you want a record that it came from the winner’s own process, so ask the winner to keep dated work files from the start.
When free concepts from the winner become your work
The winner’s pitch concepts you use should be named in the contract and covered by the same terms as other deliverables, so no idea sits in a grey zone. For those broader terms, read who owns agency creative assets.
The checklist, in order: decide whether to ask, decide whether to pay, send terms before work starts, notify the losers, then name the winner’s concepts in the contract.
Next step
Browse vetted agencies to build your shortlist, or list your agency free.
FAQ
Can I use an agency’s pitch concepts if I do not hire them?
Generally not without agreement, because the agency usually keeps the rights unless they are transferred in writing. Get terms before the pitch and ask a lawyer in your jurisdiction, since rules vary.
Is it normal to pay agencies for pitch work?
It is a fair option, not a universal norm. A fee signals seriousness and gives written rights terms something to attach to, so state it in the brief before anyone starts.
Sources
- US Copyright Office, What is copyright?, fetched 2026-10-11
- US Copyright Office, Circular 30, fetched 2026-10-11
- GOV.UK, Copyright, fetched 2026-10-11
- GOV.UK, License and sell your copyright, fetched 2026-10-11
—LEDGER—
{“verified”: [{“claim”: “Once you create an original work and fix it you are the author and owner; copyright protects expression and never ideas or concepts.”, “url”: “https://www.copyright.gov/what-is-copyright/”, “status”: 200, “checked”: “2026-10-11”}, {“claim”: “Works made for hire: hiring party treated as author in defined situations.”, “url”: “https://www.copyright.gov/circs/circ30.pdf”, “status”: 200, “checked”: “2026-10-11”}, {“claim”: “UK copyright arises automatically on creation.”, “url”: “https://www.gov.uk/copyright”, “status”: 200, “checked”: “2026-10-11”}, {“claim”: “UK transfer of copyright requires a written, signed document.”, “url”: “https://www.gov.uk/copyright/license-and-sell-your-copyright”, “status”: 200, “checked”: “2026-10-11”}],
“evidence_gaps”: [“Trade body position on spec work: no resolvable official page found, so the post makes no claim about it.”, “Where the idea/expression line falls for a campaign concept: deferred to counsel in the text.”],
“word_count”: 1240}